Posts Tagged ‘humanitarian work’

Is Development Work a Sham?

Sunday, February 14th, 2010

Portrait10We spent this weekend shooting 4-year-olds at a preschool which is one in a series of “pilot program” preschools that are supposed to improve the overall quality of education in Bangladesh. The theory is, if kids are more prepared for primary school, they will stay in school longer and lower the 40% dropout rate. And, as the story goes, with more education, kids will grow up to be more productive adults, ending the cycle of poverty and causing real social change and decreased poverty. Meanwhile, my Bangladeshi co-workers, who themselves have defeated the cycle of poverty (after all, they have good jobs working at my company, are well educated, and support their families), don’t want their kids to grow up in Bangladesh. And they certainly don’t want them to be educated here. It seems that the people of this country have lost hope themselves in any sort of large-scale, developmental change.

I pondered this dramatic inconsistency during our entire shoot. I used to think that development was development, no matter who did it: faith-based NGOs, or strictly needs-based secular NGOs. People need food in their mouths and clothes on their backs, right? People need a sustainable way to live beyond a hand-to-mouth existence. And that in itself is the purpose of development. If you want to proselytize along the way, that is great, as long as the immediate need is being met; after all, people won’t listen to how much Jesus loves them if you’re not meeting their in-the-moment needs also. But our work with this secular NGO is really changing my opinion. Because if education gets better, and then the educated just flee the country, then what hope is there of making a lasting impact on government or society? The dramatically overlooked factor here is the power of faith and morality to affect a society: the overwhelming impact that the gospel of Christ has on a society whose highest value is not getting caught. This country of supposedly religious people values an honor vs. shame sort of facade, but when it comes down to it, their belief has no moral impact on their actions. And it is only education coupled with an upbringing in integrity – integrity not based on rules and discipline, but on a condition of the heart – that will cause major societal change in Bangladesh. (more…)

Advanced ‘Deshing

Monday, February 8th, 2010

Living in the DeshI am now one week into my second visit to one of the most unglamorous and remote parts of the world: Bangladesh. While it may seem that, surrounded by the up-and-comers on the world’s financial scene, like India and China one one side, and southeast Asian tourist hubs like Thailand, Cambodia, Nepal and Vietnam on the other side, Bangladesh must be one of the “small, but steaming ahead” sites of world development that you just don’t hear much about. Perhaps factories are thriving and Bollywood culture is beating out the heart of this soon-to-be prosperous people. Or perhaps it’s one of those hidden gems: the final frontier for “off the beaten track” tourism.

Well, if you were tempted to think any of those things about Bangladesh, let me be the first of many to inform you that you’re wrong. Bangladesh is as close to the Somalias and Zimbabwes of the world in terms of poverty as you can get in Asia, and is trailing just behind the likes of Chad, Iraq, and Sudan on the list of world’s most corrupt countries. The highly Muslim society is a less extreme and dangerous place than some of its Middle Eastern counterparts, but the appalling lack of respect for women is still at work in the shame-and-respect tone of society. Dowrys are expected for a successful marriage in most parts of the country, and women are commonly raped by family members. And, with half the population of the United States in a country roughly the size of Ireland, there’s certainly no manifest destiny going on over here either. (more…)